To Top
PlayNetwork Independent US gambling guides · state by state You're on PlayNJ

Kalshi’s Maryland Loss Deepens Split Over NJ Sports Betting Laws

A Fourth Circuit majority backed Maryland’s authority to apply gambling rules to Kalshi, taking the opposite position from a Third Circuit panel in the New Jersey dispute.
The Kalshi logo: Kalshi court filing on desk
PlayNJ News Team Avatar
2 mins read
Share Share
Copy link Share on X Share on Facebook Share on Reddit Share via Email

A Fourth Circuit majority rejected Kalshi’s argument that federal law shields its sports event contracts from Maryland gambling regulation, deepening an appellate split that includes a contrary ruling over New Jersey sports betting laws.

This image was created entirely by AI with guidance from our editorial team.

Logo: Kalshi Inc. (public domain) / Wikimedia Commons

The decision leaves in place a Maryland federal judge’s denial of an injunction that would have blocked the state from requiring Kalshi to obtain a sports betting license, according to Courthouse News Service.

Federal courts diverge over state gambling authority

The Fourth Circuit joined the Sixth and Ninth Circuits in ruling that states can regulate Kalshi. A divided Third Circuit panel reached the opposite conclusion, determining that the Commodity Exchange Act prevents New Jersey sports betting laws from regulating Kalshi’s sports event contracts.

Kalshi argued that the act gives the Commodity Futures Trading Commission exclusive jurisdiction over swaps. Writing for the Fourth Circuit majority, U.S. Circuit Judge Roger Gregory concluded that Congress had not clearly intended to displace state gambling laws.

“Congress knows how to displace traditional state police powers when it chooses to do so. Here, it has not done so with the clarity our precedents require,” Gregory wrote.

The majority described Maryland’s law as imposing generally applicable conditions on businesses offering sports event contracts in the state, including licensing obligations and advertising restrictions.

Judges disagree on whether sports contracts are swaps

U.S. Circuit Judge Stephanie Thacker joined Gregory’s majority opinion but wrote separately to argue that sports event contracts are not swaps subject to the commission’s exclusive regulatory authority. U.S. Circuit Judge DeAndrea Gist Benjamin dissented, concluding that the contracts are swaps.

Maryland Attorney General Anthony Brown welcomed the decision, saying Kalshi must meet the same consumer protection standards as sportsbooks serving Maryland residents.

Kalshi spokesperson Elizabeth Diana challenged the judges’ differing reasoning.

“This splintered decision, including three separate contradictory opinions, demonstrates there is no unified coherent legal argument against prediction markets,” Diana said, according to Courthouse News Service.

Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.

More from playnj.com

—

Source: As reported by Courthouse News Service.

AI Disclosure
This content was created, reviewed, and approved by PlayNJ News Team. We use AI to help draft and refine text, but every review, news piece, and update goes through our editorial team before publishing. See our Editor Guidelines for more.
About the Author
VIEW ALL POSTS

The PlayNJ News Team provides everything you need to know about online casinos, retail casinos in Atlantic City, sports betting (online and retail), lottery, and all other legal gambling in New Jersey. The content writing process for the PlayNJ News Team uses an AI application, but the content is edited and fact-checked by real humans. No piece of content is published before human eyes take a fine-tooth comb to ensure its accuracy, reliability, and trustworthiness.

VIEW ALL POSTS