Better Markets, Allison Herren Lee and John Coates have filed an amicus brief arguing that the Commodity Futures Trading Commission unlawfully allowed Kalshi and other exchanges to offer single-stock perpetuals as futures, according to Sportico.com, which reported the challenge Nov. 17. The brief argues those products are security-based swaps subject to Securities and Exchange Commission oversight.
The challenge concerns stock-linked contracts, while Kalshi’s sports event contracts remain the subject of a separate regulatory dispute involving New Jersey.
Brief disputes CFTC authority over stock perpetuals
Kalshi introduced perpetuals linked to individual stock price movements earlier this month, Sportico.com reported. The products allow round-the-clock speculation on stock price changes without owning the stock.
The brief argues that single-stock perpetuals are best understood as contracts for difference and therefore security-based swaps. It says the SEC and CFTC reached that determination in 2012. The filing also argues that high leverage, no expiration and automatic forced liquidation make the products uniquely risky.
The Capital Markets Alliance supports the brief and argues that the CFTC’s classification exceeds its statutory authority. Its position is that contracts without an expiration or delivery date are swaps rather than security futures. CME Group made the same argument in a separate lawsuit against the CFTC this summer.
Kalshi disputed the criticism in a statement to Sportico.com: “We agree with the CFTC that these are legitimate futures.” The company also argued that opposition comes from incumbents concerned about innovation and losing clients.
New Jersey litigation is part of sports-contract split
Sportico.com reported that federal appellate courts have split over whether Kalshi’s sports event contracts qualify as swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act.
The 9th and 6th Circuits concluded that the contracts do not qualify as swaps. The 3rd Circuit reached the opposite conclusion and accepted Kalshi’s federal-preemption position in its New Jersey litigation.
The Trump administration has defended the CFTC’s authority over sports event contracts. Some members of Congress are pushing legislation to prohibit CFTC-regulated platforms from offering sports and casino-style event contracts.
More from playnj.com
- Kalshi Seeks Dismissal Of $580K Suit, Citing Broader Sports Contract Disputes
- Novig Denied New York Injunction As Judge Calls Sports Contracts Betting
- Better Markets Urges 2nd Circuit to Side With New York in Kalshi Appeal
Source: As reported by Sportico.com.