Two New Jersey bills would restrict and tax prediction markets, according to New Jersey Hills, as lawmakers in 14 states have proposed 50 bills centered on wagering apps such as Kalshi and Polymarket.
Assembly Member Balvir Singh introduced A4689 in March. The bill would bar betting on death markets, war and terrorism, natural disasters, mass shootings or politics. It would also require prediction markets to acquire a New Jersey license for sports gambling. A separate bill, A5336, would charge a 9% surtax on income generated by prediction markets.
What Singh’s bill targets
Singh said certain markets do not match the state’s values. “Certain markets, I don’t believe, that New Jersey’s values align with what they’re selling,” he said, referring to wagers involving assassinations, catastrophes and elections.
He also described the bill as a states’ rights measure. “The prediction markets right now are really kind of infringing upon on what is really a states right. What the bill is saying is that we understand the federal supremacy clause, but gambling, sports betting, is a state’s space,” Singh said.
PlayNJ reported in June that the New Jersey Senate president filed a bill to regulate and tax prediction markets.
State-federal dispute before the Supreme Court
New Jersey Attorney General Jennifer Davenport asked the U.S. Supreme Court to determine whether prediction markets must follow state gambling laws after conflicting appellate court rulings. The case is Mary Jo Flaherty, Interim Director, New Jersey Division of Gaming Enforcement v. Kalshi. An alliance of 145 Indian tribes has filed legal briefs urging the court to rule in the case.
Polymarket US maintains that prediction markets are regulated by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission under a federal framework, “not a patchwork of state rules,” according to a written statement quoted in the article. Kalshi spokesperson Dani Lever previously said, “Kalshi is an open, nationwide financial exchange. It cannot be regulated by 50 different regulators,” in a statement reported by the New Jersey Monitor.
Actions in other states
In Missouri, Attorney General Catherine Hanaway issued cease-and-desist orders against six prediction market operators for unlicensed, untaxed sports betting. She wrote to Polymarket, Kalshi, Crypto.com, Novig, Underdog and Robinhood, demanding that they stop providing sports betting or comply with Missouri taxes, fees and age restrictions. Legal Missouri sportsbooks must pay 10% of total wagers in taxes and a $500,000 licensing fee. The article notes that 50.05% of Missourians voted in 2024 to legalize sports betting.
In Ohio, Rep. Sean Brennan introduced House Bill 887 in May to prohibit public employees and officials from participating in prediction markets. “We don’t want to see public service become an opportunity to monetize privileged information,” Erika White said of the measure.
A California bill passing through committee proposes that the attorney general investigate any payout of $5,000 or more. Tennessee enacted a law making it a felony to intentionally manipulate the outcome of an event to profit from a prediction market. In Georgia, four bills and resolutions introduced in the last legislative session to regulate the industry all failed.
The U.S. Supreme Court has not yet decided whether it will hear the New Jersey case against Kalshi.
More from playnj.com
- NJ Self-Exclusion Program Features in GamStop Comparison
- Evolution Gets NJ Approval For Showboat Live Dealer Center
- NJ Online Casino Win Tops Atlantic City Again In September
Source: As reported by New Jersey Hills.